A Library Management Cautionary Tale

Reading time ( words)

The library management of footprints, land patterns, or cells—however you refer to them in your ecosystem—is one of the most critical items in the foundation of any PCB or CCA design. When I was asked to write an article on this topic, so many thoughts and experiences instantly flooded my mind. After 30+ years of designing PCBs throughout the industry, I have my share of experiences and stories about footprints.

One particular experience stands out—a project that I consulted on several years ago. My friend Vino asked if I could support a project that he was about to kick off. I said sure, as I had worked with him many times before. We discussed the initial PCB layout details, and we noted the extremely tight, aggressive schedule he was up against.

As we were planning our attack, the topic of library part creation came up, as usual. But this time, Vino wanted to farm out the library efforts to a third-party company that was unknown to me. I voiced my concerns about using this resource, and the importance of library parts being accurate and correct. Vino assured me that we’d be okay because this company came with high recommendations from a trusted source. I trust Vino, so a few meetings later, everything was put into motion.

The design at hand was a small, complex backplane card targeted for the end-product to go to a data center customer. The PCB measured 8” x 3.” It had 14 layers, 0.062” thick, with about 1,000 parts, and eight cluster modules containing 2 x 2.5 Gbps per link on each of these modules. This is a high-speed digital design, with around 40 Gbps data rates and very fast edge rates. It also featured two additional daughter cards, two network switches and a backplane controller BGA consisting of several hundred pins. The team worked like crazy and hit all the initial targeted phase gates within the project schedule. After lots of analyses done on the design, including a final DFM check, the design went out for fabrication as scheduled, with no apparent issues. Happy ending! Or was it?

About four weeks later, I was at the office when Vino called my cellphone. I answered, expecting to hear some early success of initial testing of the assembly. But I knew something was wrong from the tone of his voice. “Steph, I need your help!”

My heartbeat quickened. Vino proceeded to tell me that upon powering up the CCA, it got extremely hot within a few seconds, especially the backplane controller BGA. He had already powered up two of the five CCAs we had built, and each had this similar issue. We scrambled, discussing possible issues that caused the overheating.

To read this entire article, which appeared in the February 2021 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.



Suggested Items

Turning ‘Garbage In, Garbage Out' into ‘Good In, Good Out’

03/23/2021 | Tamara Jovanovic, Happiest Baby
In the PCB design cycle, it is so easy to unintentionally introduce “garbage” into your system. Unless you have time to extensively check everything you bring in from an external source, it is very likely that something will not match up with your design data. In the end, this means you’ll have to put more work into your design and basically reverse-engineer a part that was supposed to save you time and effort.

Karen McConnell: Recipient of the IPC Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame Award

03/11/2021 | Patty Goldman, I-Connect007
"I heard about IPC when I started a new job at UNISYS after graduating college. I moved from ASIC design to printed circuit boards," said Karen McConnell after being inducted into the Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame. "At the time, in the late ’80s and early ’90s, there were rumors going around that printed circuit boards were going to disappear, and ASICs were going to take over the world. But something in printed circuit boards fascinated me. I minored in robotics in college as an electrical engineer and the data used to fabricate, assemble and test the boards is actually all robotic language. I was hooked."

The Key to Eliminating Bad Design Data: Constant Vigilance

03/09/2021 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
The I-Connect007 editorial team recently met with Jen Kolar and Mark Thompson of Monsoon Solutions to discuss ways to eliminate bad data from the design process, whether that be from CAD libraries, parts vendors, chip makers, or customers themselves. They key in on some problems and obstacles that allow incorrect data into the design cycle, and then highlight possible solutions.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.