-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- design007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueLevel Up Your Design Skills
This month, our contributors discuss the PCB design classes available at IPC APEX EXPO 2024. As they explain, these courses cover everything from the basics of design through avoiding over-constraining high-speed boards, and so much more!
Opportunities and Challenges
In this issue, our expert contributors discuss the many opportunities and challenges in the PCB design community, and what can be done to grow the numbers of PCB designers—and design instructors.
Embedded Design Techniques
Our expert contributors provide the knowledge this month that designers need to be aware of to make intelligent, educated decisions about embedded design. Many design and manufacturing hurdles can trip up designers who are new to this technology.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - design007 Magazine
Calculation of Frequency-Dependent Effective Roughness Dielectric Parameters for Copper Foil Using Equivalent Capacitance Models
January 2, 2019 | Marina Y. Koledintseva, Metamagnetics Inc.*, and Tracey Vincent, CST of AmericaEstimated reading time: 20 minutes
Printed circuit boards (PCBs) used in high-speed digital design are known to have a substantial level of copper foil roughness which compromises signal integrity (SI) and may also cause electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) problems. Therefore, knowledge of the correct parameters of laminate PCB dielectrics refined from any copper foil roughness impact and the proper foil roughness characterization are important constituents of modeling high-speed digital electronics designs, see, e.g., [1,2,3] and references therein.
The Effective Roughness Dielectric (ERD) concept was introduced in [4,5,6]. ERD is a homogeneous lossy dielectric layer of certain thickness Tr with effective (averaged) dielectric constant DKr and dissipation factor DFr. ERD is placed on a smooth conductor surface to substitute an inhomogeneous transition layer between a conductor and laminate substrate dielectric. While the concept is simple, it is physically illuminating, meaningful, and powerful. It has been successfully applied to model conductor (copper foil) roughness in printed circuit boards for signal integrity (SI) and electromagnetic interference (EMI) purposes when designing high-speed digital electronics devices [7,8]. The ERD model has been implemented and tested in a number of numerical electromagnetic modeling tools, see, e.g., [9,10,11,12].
In our previous publications [6,13,14], the ERD “design curves”, determining the ranges of the DKr and DFr parameters for different types of PCB copper foils, were developed. The methodology of generating these “design curves” is based on the following procedures:
- Stripline S-parameter Sweep (S3) technique to measure S-parameters of single-ended comparatively long (~40 cm, or 16 inches) striplines with TRL calibration to remove connector effects [15,16];
- Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) or high-resolution optical microscopy of cross-sections of PCB samples with signal traces and the proper quantification of surface roughness profile parameters [17,18,19];
- Differential Extrapolation Roughness Measurement (DERM) technique [20,21,22]; and
- 2D-FEM and/or 3D FIT numerical modeling that allow for accurately fitting the measured S-parameters of the striplines and extract the data for DKr and DFr of the roughness layers [4,6,13,14]. This fitting may include an optimization procedure, e.g., a genetic algorithm, to minimize the discrepancy between the modeled and measured S-parameters.
The "design curves" in the abovementioned papers were generated using SEM and/or optical microscopy to quantify foil roughness. Any designer can use these “design curves” and does not necessarily need to cut a PCB and prepare samples of the lines cross-sections for microscopic inspection. It is sufficient to know which type of foil is used in the PCB under test – this may be standard (STD) foil, VLP (very low profile), RTF (reverse-treated foil), or HVLP (hyper-very low profile)/ SVLP (super-very low profile) foil. Each foil type (group) has some ranges of DKr, DFr, and Tr values, and a designer may take average values DKr, DFr, and Tr within these ranges for the reasonable estimation of the data which then could be used in modeling of the PCB designs.
Although the “design curves” were developed using fitting between the experimental data and modeling results, it is always desirable to have an analytical model. In this work, the DKr and DFr parameters are derived based on the understanding that the transition layer between the dielectric and foil contains gradual variation of concentration of metallic inclusions: from zero concentration in laminate dielectric through some percolation limit to 100% at the smooth copper foil level. The equivalent material parameters of this layered structure can be obtained using equivalent capacitance approach. In the equivalent capacitor the dielectric properties vary gradually according to the concentration profile of metallic particles in the roughness layer. The concentration profile can be obtained from SEM or high-resolution optical microscopy. As concentration of metallic particles increases along the axis normal to the laminate dielectric and foil boundary, two regions can be determined: insulating (pre-percolation) and conducting (percolation). Rates of increase of effective loss (or effective conductivity) in these two regions significantly differ. The proposed model of equivalent capacitance with gradient dielectric has been applied to STD and VLP foils, and the results are validated using 3D numerical electromagnetic simulations.
Description of Equivalent Capacitance Model
A roughness profile on a PCB conductor surface can be tested using optical or SEM microscopy, or a surface profiler. The average contents (volume concentration) of metallic particles in the roughness layer varies as a function of the coordinate z normal to the surface. It can be approximated by an exponential function,
(1)
where a and K1 are the fitting parameters.
Two separate regions of effective roughness dielectric can be considered:
Region I: 0p, where the concentration of metallic inclusions is below the percolation threshold, i.e., where the mixture remains in the dielectric phase; this is the region adjacent to the dielectric matrix of the PCB. Herein, Tp is the distance within the layer at which percolation is reached.
Region II: Tp, where the concentration of metallic inclusions is higher than the percolation threshold; this is the region adjacent to the smooth foil level and is conducting. Herein, T is the entire thickness of ERD layer. It includes,
(2)
where ΔT is the thickness of the region above the percolation.
The concentration , at which percolation will occur for the metallic particles in the roughness dielectric layer, can be obtained empirically, i.e., estimated from the microscopy pictures, or from the profiler data. By solving the equation,
(3)
with respect to Tp, one can get the height of the dielectric phase of ERD.
First, let us consider the region 0p. This is the dielectric layer with relative permittivity varying according to the profile function (1) from the matrix dielectric properties em (at z=0) to the final pre-percolation value ep (at z=Tp). Since dielectric function varies with z as,
(4)
The effective permittivity of such a layer can be calculated through the equivalent partial layered capacitor consisting of series connection of sublayer capacitors. The capacitance of the resultant capacitor with variable properties of the dielectric is,
(5)
where C0 is the capacitance of the corresponding air-filled rectangular parallel-plate capacitor of thickness, d. Herein, d = Tp.
The effective dielectric properties of such dielectric layer can be easily derived from (5) as
(6)
Page 1 of 4
Suggested Items
Insulectro’s 'Storekeepers' Extend Their Welcome to Technology Village at IPC APEX EXPO
04/03/2024 | InsulectroInsulectro, the largest distributor of materials for use in the manufacture of PCBs and printed electronics, welcomes attendees to its TECHNOLOGY VILLAGE during this year’s IPC APEX EXPO at the Anaheim Convention Center, April 9-11, 2024.
ENNOVI Introduces a New Flexible Circuit Production Process for Low Voltage Connectivity in EV Battery Cell Contacting Systems
04/03/2024 | PRNewswireENNOVI, a mobility electrification solutions partner, introduces a more advanced and sustainable way of producing flexible circuits for low voltage signals in electric vehicle (EV) battery cell contacting systems.
Heavy Copper PCBs: Bridging the Gap Between Design and Fabrication, Part 1
04/01/2024 | Yash Sutariya, Saturn Electronics ServicesThey call me Sparky. This is due to my talent for getting shocked by a variety of voltages and because I cannot seem to keep my hands out of power control cabinets. While I do not have the time to throw the knife switch to the off position, that doesn’t stop me from sticking screwdrivers into the fuse boxes. In all honesty, I’m lucky to be alive. Fortunately, I also have a talent for building high-voltage heavy copper circuit boards. Since this is where I spend most of my time, I can guide you through some potential design for manufacturability (DFM) hazards you may encounter with heavy copper design.
Trouble in Your Tank: Supporting IC Substrates and Advanced Packaging, Part 5
03/19/2024 | Michael Carano -- Column: Trouble in Your TankDirect metallization systems based on conductive graphite or carbon dispersion are quickly gaining acceptance worldwide. Indeed, the environmental and productivity gains one can achieve with these processes are outstanding. In today’s highly competitive and litigious environment, direct metallization reduces costs associated with compliance, waste treatment, and legal issues related to chemical exposure. What makes these processes leaders in the direct metallization space?
AT&S Shines with Purest Copper on World Recycling Day
03/18/2024 | AT&SThe Styrian microelectronics specialist AT&S is taking World Recycling Day as an opportunity to review the progress that has been made in recent months at its sites around the world in terms of the efficient use of resources: