Rogers’ John Coonrod on Insertion Loss


Reading time ( words)

Matties: You've talked about different manufacturing processes.  How does an OEM or buyer of that technology verify this before they get into a problem situation?

Coonrod: That's a good question, actually. Because normally an OEM designs a board and sends it off for the fabricator to build it, and they put on there what they are interested in, of course, for conductor widths, what kind of finish they want and things like that. That gives the PCB fabricator a lot of room to do a lot of different things. Normally, the OEMs don't specify some of the things that I'm going to be talking about today, and in some ways I hope what I'm going to talk about will be enlightening for the OEMs, but also for the PCB fabricators too—that they need to be more aware of how they build the boards sometimes for the OEMs. I'm not sure if that really answers your question or not though... (laughs)

Coonrod Geek 1.JPG

Matties: Well, it sounds like there's no real answer.

Coonrod: No, not really.

Matties: Other than that they can be aware of the problem. If the OEM is aware of the nature of the problem is there a specification where they can come in and say, "We want it manufactured like this"?

Coonrod: There are some cases, as you will see when I go through my presentation, where they can put a spec on things and say, "Okay, it has to be within this window," and then that takes care of the problem. In other cases it is the nature of the beast, and either the OEM has to realize that their design is going to have this wider range than they expected or they have to re-design and do something different.

Matties: Is this a prevalent problem in the industry?

Coonrod: It's a pretty big deal, I think. Really what happens is a lot of the fabricators that have been in the industry a long time have learned these lessons along the way, so they are already doing a lot of this automatically and you just don’t run into this problem with some of the really experienced people. Then, in some cases, the OEMs are doing things that they haven't tried to do before because they are pushing the limits of technology and they're trying do different things with materials and processes that haven't be done before. So every now and then when you get the right combination, unexpected things can happen.

Matties: What does a designer need to be aware of in this process?

Coonrod: What I'm going to show today is about four major topics in the PCB fabrication process that can affect the performance of the RF board. One of them is copper plating thickness, because it's very common, obviously, to plate copper through the circuit. But copper plating thickness variation, how much it varies from one circuit to another, has a pretty big role on one type of design but not as much on another type of design. So I kind of split that up today, showing that copper plating thickness is more important with some designs than in other designs.

Then there is the plated finish, which is used a lot, where they put electroless nickel immersion gold (ENIG) on copper in order to have a good reliable board for a long period of time. ENIG is a good process, but there are some things that it does that causes more insertion loss. But with certain designs it causes more insertion loss than in other designs, so that's another thing where there are certain designs that can use ENIG and not have as much loss as others. The other two topics are copper surface roughness, which is a really big topic and I’m just going to scratch the surface today, and then the last one is solder mask, and that is another topic that comes up from time to time.

Matties: It sounds like once you find the right recipe, stick with it.

Coonrod: Yes, that is true. I think that's how lots of engineers are. Once you've got something that works, don't mess with it.

Matties: But isn't that a trap?

Coonrod: It can be, yes. Especially if you are trying to deal with new technologies. A lot of times when you're breaking out a new technology you have to do something different and you have no choice but to go out on a limb. And that's kind of what some of this presentation is. I'm really sharing my learning experiences of different things I've heard and seen in the industry or helped troubleshoot, and just trying to make sure everyone is aware of these potential hazards.

Matties: John, thanks for spending time with us. I look forward to your presentation.

Coonrod: Great, thank you.

Share




Suggested Items

HDI, A-SAP and mSAP: A Designer’s Point of View

10/26/2022 | Cherie Litson, CID+, Litson1 Consulting
HDI—high-density interconnect—designs require some different thinking on the part of the designer. One of the first things to consider is whether you need HDI, and if so, how much. The HDI option comes into play as soon as you purchase any components with 0.5 mm pin pitch. The number of these components and other specifications of your design will determine the amount of HDI you will need. Here’s a quick list of HDI options.

DFM 101: Final Finishes ENEPIG and IAg

09/29/2022 | Anaya Vardya, American Standard Circuits
One of the biggest challenges facing PCB designers is not understanding the cost drivers in the PCB manufacturing process. This article is the latest in a series that will discuss these cost drivers (from the PCB manufacturer’s perspective) and the design decisions that will impact product reliability. Final finishes provide a surface for the component assembler to either solder, wire bond, or conductively attach a component pad or lead to a pad, hole, or area of a PCB. The other use for a final finish is to provide a known contact resistance and life cycle for connectors, keys, or switches. The primary purpose of a final finish is to create electrical and thermal continuity with a surface of the PCB.

Happy’s Design Tips for Material Conservation

08/25/2022 | Happy Holden, I-Connect007
For this issue, Happy Holden provided a range of options for designers who are seeking to conserve materials in their next design. He also offered an example of the relative cost index, or RCI, that he developed at HP exclusively for PCB design. With this RCI, designers can figure out the relative cost of a new design compared to an eight-layer through-hole board. We hope you can use this handy formula on your next design job.



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.