Beyond Design: DDR3/4 Fly-by vs. T-topology Routing


Reading time ( words)

JEDEC introduced fly-by topology in the DDR3 specification for the differential clock, address, command and control signals. The advantage of fly-by topology is that it supports higher-frequency operation, reduces the quantity and length of stubs and consequently improves signal integrity and timing on heavily loaded signals. Fly-by topology also reduces simultaneous switching noise (SSN) by deliberately causing flight-time skew, between the address group and the point-to-point topology signals, of the data groups. To account for this skew, the DDR3/4 controller supports write leveling. The controller must add the write leveling delays to each byte lane to maintain the strobe to clock requirement at the SDRAMs.

T-topology can be challenging to route, particularly double T-topology with four back-to-back SDRAMs, but it can be advantageous when using multi-die packages. The fly-by topology used in Figure 3 is much easier to route but does not work well with high-capacitance loads, such as LPDDR3 DDP (double die package) and QDP (quad die package) devices. IC fabricators basically arrange dies in parallel to increase package density which can also increase input capacitance by up to four times. Excessive ring-back is often present in the first few nodes of the daisy chain.

This is the reason why the T-topology was developed. However, if you are supporting only SDP (single die package) devices, then the fly-by is the most straightforward approach. It doesn't matter which topology you use, though—both fly-by and double T-topologies should work fine. If you are using a DDP device, then double-T topology works better than fly-by in terms of delivering a better system margin.

During a write cycle, using the fly-by topology, data strobe groups are launched at separate intervals to coincide with the clock arriving at memory components on the SODIMM or PCB, and must meet the timing parameter between the memory clock and DQS defined as tDQSS of ± 0.25 tCK. The PCB design process can be simplified using the leveling feature of the DDR3/4. The fly-by, daisy chain topology increases the complexity of the controller design to achieve leveling but fortunately, greatly improves performance and eases board layout for DDR3/4 designs.

To read this entire article, which appeared in the April 2016 issue of The PCB Design Magazine, click here.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

January 2019 Issue of Design007 Magazine Available Now

01/15/2019 | I-Connect007
The component shortage is getting crazy. Some PCB designers are finding their favorite capacitors on 50-week and 80-week lead times, or worse. How do you design a board today when the components you need won’t be available for a year or more? In the January 2019 issue of Design007 Magazine, we asked our expert contributors to explain the current component shortage, as well as some of the workarounds that can help you get your next design out the door sooner rather than later.

A Fractal Conversation with Jim Howard and Greg Lucas

01/15/2019 | Barry Matties and Andy Shaughnessy, I-Connect007
Veteran PCB technologists Jim Howard and Greg Lucas have made an interesting discovery: Certain shapes of copper planes make a PCB run more efficiently than other shapes, a process they dubbed fractal design. It doesn’t appear to cost a penny more, and testing suggests that fractal design techniques could eliminate edge noise. Barry Matties and Andy Shaughnessy asked Jim and Greg to discuss the fractal design process, and the advantages of using this technique.

Rainer Beerhalter Discusses His AltiumLive Munich Presentation

01/11/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
Rainer Beerhalter is a physicist, and according to his design bureau’s website, “founder, owner, and mastermind” of B GMBH. Rainer attended the first AltiumLive in Munich in 2017, and he’s returning to this year’s event in Munich January 15–17. I asked him to tell us about the class he’ll be teaching in Munich, and why he decided to come back for the sophomore AltiumLive show.



Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.