Designing in a Vacuum Q&A: Nick Barbin

Reading time ( words)

Optimum Design Associates President Nick Barbin has worn a lot of hats in this industry, from PCB designer to EMS company owner. We asked Nick to share his thoughts on what it’s like to design in a vacuum, while offering some strategies for escaping the vacuum. 

Andy Shaughnessy: How often do you design a board without knowing who is going to fabricate and/or assemble it?  

Nick Barbin: As a PCB design service provider, we are generally not always privy to this information unless we ask, and at Optimum, we do ask. It’s not so much that we care about the “who” aspect; it’s more about being in alignment with the specific manufacturer’s capabilities to ensure we are providing a design that meets our customer’s objectives for cost and reliability. This is especially important in the case of fabrication shops where capabilities tend to vary dramatically and can result in the shop requesting to modify the artwork to be able to meet the specifications called out. 

Shaughnessy: Why do so many designers not know who is going to manufacture their boards?  

Barbin: In the case of fabrication shops, once an OEM has qualified multiple vendors to build their boards, purchasing departments will consider that part number a commodity item, since it is generally one of the highest-cost items on any given bill of materials (BOM). In some cases, the OEM allows the commodity manager (CM) to choose the fabrication vendor. Because of these dynamics, it is very difficult for designers to keep track of specific vendors. Designers should have a pretty good idea of who their CM partner is, as most OEMs have one strategic vendor they rely on. Global time differences and language barriers may also contribute to designers not knowing who’s manufacturing their boards.  

Shaughnessy: What other missing information or data do you find yourself having to “design around?” 

Barbin: We believe designing around missing data is a mistake with unknown consequences. If there are missing datasheets or constraints that are truly missing, all efforts must be made to acquire the data or receive a satisfactory sign-off before moving forward. I cannot think of one instance where anything else would be acceptable. 

Shaughnessy: When you find yourself designing in a vacuum, what tricks have you devised as workarounds to get the job done? 

Barbin: Whether we are designing in a vacuum, at Optimum, we have documented our DFM (design for manufacturing) guidelines in our Designer Handbook so each of our designers have best DFM practices at their fingertips. Additionally, each designer has a checklist of over 90 items, many of which pertain to DFM, that must be checked off as completed or considered for each design that is delivered. This is part of our ISO 9001-2015 quality control system. Lastly, each design must pass through a DFM check using the Valor NPI software from Siemens. It is Optimum’s objective to ensure each of our designers deliver data for their respective designs to the downstream manufacturers that is both comprehensive and manufacturable to each of our customer requirements. 

Shaughnessy: What are some of the hidden costs, in addition to monetary, of designing in a vacuum? 

Barbin: Delayed time to market certainly comes to mind. The minute a released manufacturing package cannot be manufactured as-is and needs to be modified, the project is immediately put on hold waiting for approvals or answers. This can delay the development cycle by days and weeks as it progresses through many email mailboxes.

To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the May 2022 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

DownStream Flexes in Rigid-Flex

11/14/2022 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
During PCB West, I caught up with DownStream Technologies co-founder Joe Clark and Senior Product Marketing Manager Mark Gallant. We discussed some of their latest tool updates, including a greater focus on bringing post-processing functionality, such as inter-layer analysis capability, to rigid-flex circuits. Joe also offered a look at global design trends going into 2023, as more engineers take on PCB designer roles while senior designers are retiring.

Sunstone’s Matt Stevenson Shares Insights From New PCB Design Book

10/27/2022 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
There’s designing the “perfect” circuit board and then there’s designing a board that is “perfect for manufacturing.” While seasoned designers and design engineers understand many of the nuances, PCB fabricator Sunstone Circuits has just published a new book specifically for new designers who have the knowledge of design but are still learning what it means to get the board manufactured. Sunstone’s Matt Stevenson takes the reader through a series of situations that should help clarify what’s happening in the fabrication process and how to adjust a board design to be better suited for manufacturing.

Forming Standards for Ultra HDI

10/25/2022 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
To get the latest news about ultra high-density interconnections (UHDI), we checked in with Jan Pedersen, NCAB Group’s director of technology. Jan is co-chair of IPC D-33AP, and a great source of overall DFM expertise as well. We asked him to give us a snapshot of UHDI in the industry, where we’re headed, and what this means to PCB designers.

Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.