The Art and Science of DFM

Reading time ( words)

Our industry has been focusing on DFM for decades, but in our reader surveys, DFM issues are always among the biggest challenges cited by respondents. I recently spoke with Vince Mazur, product and persona marketing engineer at Altium, about the art and science of PCB design, and particularly design for manufacturing. Is DFM an art form in itself?

Andy Shaughnessy: We often hear that PCB design is part art, part science, a matter of right brain and left brain. Do you think it’s more of one than the other, or does it depend on the design job?

Vince Mazur: I think it depends on the design job. For example, for impedance-controlled, high-speed PCB design, the priority is performance-to-spec, not the expression or application of creative skill and imagination, which is a common definition of art. The designer must choose the right materials and define the “right” stackup. By that, I mean the materials and geometry that science tells us will realize the desired impedances. If the designer chooses an incorrect stackup, it doesn’t matter how pleasant the PCB looks, how optimized the placement and routing is, or how much expression or creative skill and imagination was deployed—it will not function as intended. The idea that science is the driver in this case is not to say that art is not present. Art most certainly is present in the all-important placement of components and routing of traces. Rather, I mean that the scientific aspect takes precedence. Art will always be present.

On the other hand, the design specifications may lend themselves to or even require more expression and creativity, especially when the design is closer to the user experience. Consider a display or series of visual indicators that may fit along a contour of a curved mechanical enclosure and implemented with a flex circuit. These types of designs are art first, science second. But I maintain, once again, that both art and science will be present. In this example, one would pay attention to bend radii and other mechanical and materials science to assure long term quality of the flex implementation.

Shaughnessy: Can someone with a great mind for science learn the artistic side of design? We hear non-degreed designers say this about EEs—that they’re too focused on the science and not enough on the art.

Mazur: Yes, I think this is possible provided the designer desires to learn more of the artistic side. Pablo Picasso’s father was a professor at a school of fine arts. Education is widely available in art, which implies that it is something that can be taught and learned. However, I believe there is a limit to what a scientifically focused person can do in art. While anything is possible, one can pursue fluency in art, but they likely would have a difficult time becoming a Picasso or a Rodin. Just as either of these artists could likely learn more about science, they likely would not become an Einstein or a Tesla. But then there are those outliers that have extreme talent in both domains, such as Galileo. So yes, it is possible for someone with a great mind for science to learn the artistic side of design.

To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the December 2021 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

Are You Offering Options in Your Bill of Materials?

03/07/2023 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
In this interview, Saline Lectronics (an Emerald EMS company) President Jason Sciberras talks about PCB designers offering packaging options in the bill of materials. As Jason explains, mil/aero manufacturers like Saline can’t make many changes to a design without getting recertified, so including approved packaging options in the BOM from the start is a great way to go. Are you offering options in your BOM?

Q&A With the IPC Design Competition Winner

02/17/2023 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007
Design engineer Sathishkumar Vijayakumar (aka Sathish Kumar V.) with Tessolve Semiconductor, India, took home top honors in this year’s IPC Design Competition, besting the other four finalists in a rigid-flex design showdown during IPC APEX EXPO. Unlike last year, no one finished the design completely, so judges graded competitors on what they did finish, as well as criteria such as design decisions they made, and whether they followed electrical and DFM rules.

PCB Designers Are Really Product Designers

02/09/2023 | Zachariah Peterson, NWES
As I look back on 2022, I’m realizing that my company plays multiple roles in client projects beyond just designing circuits and PCBs. Sure, we’re primarily a PCB design company, but we also help with things that happen outside the PCB. This includes tasks like enclosure design, defining mechanical constraints, simulating electrical behavior, mating boards into larger assemblies, selecting cabling, and defining test requirements, all of which slowly creep into the standard scope of work for design projects.

Copyright © 2023 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.