Barry Olney’s High-Speed Simulation Primer


Reading time ( words)

The I-Connect007 editorial team recently spoke with Barry Olney of iCD about simulation. Barry, a columnist for Design007 Magazine, explains why simulation tools can have such a steep learning curve, and why many design engineers are still not using simulation on complex high-speed designs.

Barry also highlights common mistakes that design engineers make using simulation tools, and he offers a variety of tips and techniques for anyone dealing with simulation challenges. Among them: Don’t trust reference designs and datasheets.

Andy Shaughnessy: What are some of the biggest problems in simulation? In our surveys, engineers say that they have trouble doing simulation and analysis. What is so tough about it?

Barry Olney: I think the biggest problem, Andy, is time, and that’s the same with PCB design in general. The PCB design is the last process in the design flow, and when I get a job for a board layout, it’s already behind schedule. I’ve never ever had a job where it was on schedule and everything was running smoothly. So, you’re pushed for time during the whole process, and to add simulation on top of that, that pushes it back another week or so. Management is reluctant to do it because they think, “Well, it may work and then we can get it through just a little bit behind schedule, but if we leave it another week then it delays things even further.” It seems they don’t have time to do it right the first time, but they’ve got the time for a re-spin.

A lot of engineering managers actually schedule in a re-spin because they believe they need at least two iterations before they get a working product. So, time is the biggest factor. That’s why they generally tend to skip simulation. There’s also the learning curve associated with the high-end tools that requires experience—not just with the tools, but with high-speed design rules. Sourcing IBIS models is another big issue. Maybe you can’t find the model, so you have to compromise. IC vendors are now supplying most IBIS models, but for FPGAs, in particular, if you get the default IBIS model from the vendor’s website, it has a default pin assignment, but once the EE places and routes the actual FPGA chip, you need to redefine the pin assignments for each signal.

Now, the pin assignment of the FPGA that someone designs isn’t the same as the one on the IBIS model, and that’s where it all goes haywire. You think, “That simulation is simple. You just have to import the IBIS models into the transmission line model and click Go.” That should happen, but, it doesn’t. Where you don’t have pin assignments matching, you have to manually select the required FPGA sub-models from the thousands of pins with 50 or so sub-models. And these have all got cryptic names that are different for each IC vendor. So, you actually have to find the model or driver model that matches the transmission line that you’re trying to simulate. Or maybe you cannot find the model at all. Good luck sourcing a connector model. So, again, this all takes time. It took me years to figure out how to do it properly, quickly, and efficiently.

To read this article, which appeared in the April 2021 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

New Book From Isola Highlights Importance of Material Selection

01/14/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
In "The Printed Circuit Designer’s Guide to... High Performance Materials," the latest release from I-007eBooks, readers will learn how to overcome challenges associated with choosing the right material for their specific application. Author Michael Gay of Isola provides a clearer picture of what to know when determining which material is the most desirable for which products. PCB materials and DFM expert Mark Thompson says, “I love this book, particularly the sections on the effects of the glass weave, the history of laminate, and the difference between Dk and effective Dk."

Living in a Material World: High-Speed Design Strategies

01/13/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Any discussion about high-speed PCB design techniques would be incomplete without considering the properties and requirements of the materials. Your material selection drives much of your design strategy when you’re operating at 28 gigabits per second or faster. We recently spoke with high-speed design expert Lee Ritchey of Speeding Edge, and electronic materials veteran Tarun Amla of Avishtech and Thintronics, about the relationship between advanced PCB materials and high-speed design techniques. They discuss the challenges facing designers and engineers working with materials at speeds that were considered unreachable not long ago, and what designers need to know about material selection as board speeds continue rising toward the stratosphere.

A High-Voltage PCB Design Primer

01/12/2022 | Zachariah Peterson, NWES
Of all the different boards a designer can create, a high voltage PCB design can be complicated and requires strict attention to safety. If not laid out correctly these boards can be safety hazards or can fail to function on first power up, leaving a designer with wasted time and effort. In the best case, the board will function reliably for a long period of time thanks to correct layout practices. High-voltage PCB design can be as complex as any high-speed digital design. Boards for high-voltage systems can be space constrained and they carry important safety requirements. They also need to be highly reliable to ensure they will have a long life when run at high voltage and current.



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.