Oops, I Did It Again: Survey Details Most Common Design Errors


Reading time ( words)

Michelle_Te_300.jpgWe hate to admit it, but even the best of us make mistakes. Such is true with PCB designers and design engineers. We wondered: What are the most common mistakes that PCB designers make?

Since no one likes to admit they make mistakes, the I-Connect007 Research Team sent that very question out in a survey. Sometimes it just feels better to remain anonymous. There’s a little more truth there.

Your responses to the survey, we found, could be divided into three categories: failures/errors, changes/improvements, and time to market. And just for fun, there’s a miscellaneous category, but more on that later.

Designers_errors_piechart_700.jpg

In what our team categorized as failures/errors, there was a wide range of responses, including “electrical functions wrong,” “part obsolescence,” “noise,” “thermal failures,” “minor design corrections,” and “performance not met.” Others cited errors with engineering, circuit design, schematics, design faults, software issues, and simply, “dumb mistakes.”

Many other respondents recognized the need to make changes and improvements. Some comments included: “Adding new functionality,” “changes in product specification,” “layout improvements,” “dimensional/shape adaptation due to altered design on housing,” “evolving requirements, learning as you go,” “out of sync with mechanical model because of last-minute changes,” “EMV improvements,” “needs for change identified during testing,” and “mechanical changes (enclosures, mounting, etc.).”

Still others responded that errors occur because of time or time-to-market. They listed these conclusions: “Short schedule limits detailed checking,” “new, unproven designs,” “rushing to production,” and “not taking the time to perform analysis of design up front.”

And finally, there were miscellaneous responses that didn’t seem to fit the above. They had to do with PCBA alignment, footprint issues, not fully appreciating mechanical tolerance chain, reducing cost, optimization, manufacturing issues and solder mask, and panelization.

If you’re a designer or work with designers, you likely recognize some of these issues. But what is to be done? In upcoming issues of Design007 Magazine, you’ll read more about these issues along the path to continuous improvement.

If you’d like to comment on a particular design error, please reach out to Editor Andy Shaughnessy and share what works or doesn’t work for you.

The I-Connect007 Research Team is just one component of the I-Connect007 Team, fully committed to the most extensive coverage of the global printed circuit board, assembly and PCB design industry.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

Karen McConnell: Recipient of the IPC Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame Award

03/11/2021 | Patty Goldman, I-Connect007
"I heard about IPC when I started a new job at UNISYS after graduating college. I moved from ASIC design to printed circuit boards," said Karen McConnell after being inducted into the Raymond E. Pritchard Hall of Fame. "At the time, in the late ’80s and early ’90s, there were rumors going around that printed circuit boards were going to disappear, and ASICs were going to take over the world. But something in printed circuit boards fascinated me. I minored in robotics in college as an electrical engineer and the data used to fabricate, assemble and test the boards is actually all robotic language. I was hooked."

Cadence’s Celsius: Don’t End up Holding the Hot Potato!

12/17/2020 | Clive "Max" Maxfield, Maxfield High-Tech Consulting
I was just thinking about the party game Hot Potato. It reminded me of today’s increasingly competitive marketplace: Accurate thermal analysis must be performed, and any potential issues have to be identified and addressed as early as possible in the design cycle. Otherwise the system will run into problems, market windows will be missed, and someone will be left holding the hot potato. Trust me, you do not want to be that someone.

Chapter 1 Excerpt from the Book ‘Thermal Management: A Fabricator's Perspective’

12/08/2020 | Anaya Vardya, American Standard Circuits
Heat cannot be efficiently exchanged with stagnant air surrounding a hot device; however, it can be transferred away from the electronic component to the PCB using thermal vias. A thermal via is a good conductor of heat that runs between the top layer and bottom layer of the PCB, dissipating heat through simple conduction. In simple terms, thermal vias are plated holes located under, or electrically connected to, a surface-mounted heat source on a PCB that allows heat transfer through the hole.



Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.