With App Notes, Trust But Verify

Reading time ( words)

For this month’s issue on app notes, I checked in with Clive “Max” Maxfield. The author of Bebop to the Boolean Boogie and countless technical articles and blog posts, he has been involved with all manner of app notes and datasheets during his long career. Max shares his thoughts on data. As he points out, “Remember that these documents are not written by an ‘infallible creator.’”

Andy Shaughnessy: Max, you’ve been involved with electronics design in a variety of different segments: ICs, PCBs, programmables, etc. Give us an overview of how you view the role of app notes vs. datasheets for a PCB designer or EE.

Clive “Max” Maxfield: First of all, you can have datasheets and app notes for all sorts of things, including subsystems, systems, products, machines, etc. From my perspective, I usually think of these in terms of electronic components—either discrete components like resistors, capacitors, diodes, transistors, or more complex components like integrated circuits, from op-amps all the way up to microcontrollers and the like. In this context of datasheets vs. app notes, they serve two different purposes. A datasheet summarizes the characteristics and performance of a component. By comparison, an app note briefly describes how a component is to be configured and used for a specific example application.

Shaughnessy: Have you ever written any datasheets or app notes?

Maxfield: I haven’t written any datasheets, but I have written a couple of application notes.

Shaughnessy: We’ve heard from some PCB designers and EEs who work for companies that demand that they follow app notes, but some well-known design instructors advise designers that IC makers’ app notes should be assumed wrong until proven right. What’s your take on this?

Maxfield: I think app notes can be really useful when you are first starting to work with a new component or with a known component in a new or “new to you” configuration or application. Having said this, I think everything you read, including datasheets and application notes, should be assumed to be lacking or misleading or indeed incorrect/wrong just in case.

Shaughnessy: It looks to me as if IC manufacturers’ datasheets are more grounded in facts, while app notes are sometimes overly optimistic. Some designers say app notes are used more like marketing materials. Is that a fairly accurate description?

To read this entire interview, which appears in the June 2020 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.



Suggested Items

Just Ask Joe: Standardized Grid Designs

08/26/2020 | I-Connect007 Research Team
First, we asked you to send in your questions for Happy Holden. Now, it’s Joe Fjelstad’s turn! Inventor, columnist, instructor, and founder of Verdant Electronics, Joe has been involved with rigid PCBs and flexible circuits for decades, and he’s ready to share some of his knowledge with our readers. We hope you enjoy “Just Ask Joe.”

Words of Advice: What are Your Biggest Design Challenges?

03/11/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
In a recent survey, we asked the following question: What are your biggest design challenges? Here are just a few of the answers, edited slightly for clarity.

The Electronic Component Shortage Crisis: A Veteran Engineer’s Perspective

02/18/2019 | John Watson, CID, Legrand Inc.
From where we stand now, at the beginning of 2019, we see lead times for some components in the short range of up to 16 weeks; medium-to-high is 32 weeks, and long lead times are as far out as 80 weeks. In other words, if we ordered a component today, it would arrive in over a year a half from now (maybe). This all started with the capacitors (we will see why later), but we now see other component series being sucked into this problem.

Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.