Design Is a Pivotal Piece of the Puzzle


Reading time ( words)

As a field applications engineer at TTM Technologies, which has fabrication and manufacturing locations around the world, Julie Ellis sees a wide variety of customer design requirements. In this interview with the I-Connect007 Editorial Team, Julie explains how PCB designers can influence the development of the PCB. She shares a variety of tips and tricks that designers can implement early in the design process to help optimize fabrication and assembly later on and keep small issues from becoming big problems downstream.

Andy Shaughnessy: Julie, with your job you have a pretty circumspect view of design and manufacturing. Can you start by giving us an idea about your job and some of the designs that you see crossing your desk?

Julie Ellis:  My main task is to support customers’ designs for manufacturability by understanding their requirements and providing stack-ups and design guidelines for rigid circuit boards that are within TTM fabrication capabilities and process tolerances. I also help customers understand how fabrication processes affect capabilities, so they accept design modifications that assist in manufacturing.

The work I see coming across my desk includes components for EV charging and power conversion, Lidar, radar, back-up and industrial scanning cameras, ultrasound, defibrillators, and glucose monitoring. They require stack-ups ranging from four-layer heavy copper boards to 32 layers with three lamination cycles and mechanical blind holes and advanced HDI, which I define as 0.4-mm pitch BGAs and smaller.

Oftentimes, I’m trying to help customers design products that can also easily be transferred over to Asia and run on mass volume production lines without any advanced requirements that add cost. I work to ensure that prototypes fabricated here in North America are already designed with pre-approved stack-ups to run without modification at the final production volume site or sites. TTM calls this Seamless Global Transfer, and it works best when implemented in the planning stages of a new design.

I also review designs for cost savings. For example, in Asia, materials are 40 to 50% of a fabricator’s cost, compared to less than 20% in the United States.  When we get into high-volume manufacturing, optimizing material utilization can save a customer several percent on the final assembly if we can keep a lowered cost on the PCB by planning the PCB dimensions to fit very well on a fabrication panel. If the circuit board is small, TTM often works with our customers to calculate the best multiple-up array with rails for assembly that can still fit optimally on the fabrication panel. The most common fab panel size is 18” x 24”, but we also mass-produce 21” x 24” panels at many sites.

Shaughnessy: Sometimes, I get the feeling that the designers don’t realize how much control they have over the final product. What are some of the common errors that you see coming in that you wish that you could just tell the designer, “If you just did this...?”

Ellis: If you just…came to me for your stack-up and design rules first, I wouldn’t have to tell you that nobody can fabricate this design in mass production. I request of my customers that they come to me at initial startup of a product before they even bother to route any circuitry, because designs get so complicated that it’s very challenging for them to go back and make changes if they’ve violated standard fabrication design guidelines. It’s really stressful to explain to an engineer why his design isn’t suitable for mass production, so I prefer to avoid that like the plague.

To read the rest of this interview, which appeared in the June 2019 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

PCB Reliability: Via Design

07/12/2019 | Greg Ziraldo, Advanced Assembly
When considering the long-term reliability of a PCB, you must take into account any vias on your board. While an invaluable and essential part of board design, vias introduce weaknesses and affect solderability. This article will discuss vias, the potential concerns that are introduced into your board through their implementation, and how to minimize those concerns to acceptable levels.

Words of Advice: What are Your Biggest Problems Related to Flex Design?

07/16/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
In a recent survey, we asked the following question: What are your biggest problems related to flex design? Here are a few of the answers, edited slightly for clarity.

Albert Gaines: Design All Comes Down to Documentation

06/28/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
During SMTA Atlanta, I spoke with Albert Gaines of HiGain Design. We discussed Albert’s belief that everything starts with design and that too many engineers and designers focus solely on the final board at the expense of the documentation, which is a designer’s most important product. Do you consider your documentation to be a critical product?



Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.