Sensible Design: Conformal Coatings - Beware the Boards that ‘Bare’ All!


Reading time ( words)

This month, I’m going to depart from my usual format of providing five essential facts about conformal coatings. Instead, I’m going to provide an account of a customer’s problem—no company names mentioned, of course—that brought into question the adhesion performance of a coating that they had been using successfully for some time. 

This problem, and its eventual solution, illustrates rather well how good record-keeping, batch traceability, and the auditing of suppliers for quality control compliance can go a long way to help resolve manufacturing issues. 

Always up for a challenge, and not wanting to ignore any production-related issue that appeared to cast a shadow over the performance of our products, we donned our detective hats and, with spyglasses at the ready, set about to discover the causes of this particularly challenging delamination problem. But first, let’s have a little bit of background. 

Our customer—a multinational firm with sites around the world—contacted us about a coating they had been using without any problems for quite some time, but for some bizarre reason was “no longer sticking” to their boards. They reported that a newly delivered batch of this conformal coating, when applied, could be peeled from the solder mask areas in a single sheet. Our preliminary queries revealed that there had been no changes made to the coating process itself. So, was the coating at fault, or was there something else we were missing?

Delving a little deeper, we discovered that our customer was using this batch of coating material at several of its sites, both within the same country as the problem site, as well as sites located in other countries. It turned out these other sites had no issues to report regarding the coating, and they confirmed that they were experiencing neither the delamination problems we were investigating, nor indeed any problems related to a lack of adhesion.  It was time to check the records. 

Following a search through their database, the customer discovered they had coated four different styles of boards using the same batch of conformal coating material. Significantly, however, all of the adhesion issues were confined to a single board style. Moreover, these adhesion issues were first reported and recorded at about the same time. 

On checking the serial numbers of the coated boards, it became apparent that the adhesion issues all began on a batch of bare boards that had been obtained from a new vendor as part of a cost-cutting measure. Samples of these incoming bare boards were subsequently analysed and found to have a surface energy of 26 dyne/cm (i.e., much, much less than the 40 dyne/cm level recommended for good adhesion). 

Our customer then decided that perhaps it was high time to audit the new board supplier. During this process, they found many corners had been cut to save time and money, but two things, in particular, stood out. Firstly, the board shop was performing multiple passes through a UV oven to “cure” the solder resist, instead of the single recommended UV pass and a secondary thermal bake. Secondly, the auditor noted a “shiny film” floating on the surface of the rinse bath during the final rinse process. 

To read this entire article, which appeared in the August 2016 issue of The PCB Design Magazine, click here.

Share


Suggested Items

John R. Watson Returns to AltiumLive in San Diego

10/03/2018 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
When AltiumLive launched last year, John R. Watson, CID, of Legrand signed up as an instructor. He’ll be presenting at this week’s AltiumLive in San Diego as well. I spoke with John recently about his AltiumLive class, and the state of PCB design. He also discussed a few tricks for designing boards with components that are currently on an 80-week lead time, and why this problem is likely to get worse before it gets better.

Institute of Circuit Technology Hayling Island Seminar

10/10/2018 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
After an extreme summer heat wave had left trees dehydrated and struggling to morph into their customary display of reds and golds, the leaves were brown and brittle as the great and good of the UK printed circuit board industry crossed the bridge from the mainland of the south coast of England to Hayling Island for the autumn seminar of the Institute of Circuit Technology on September 20, 2018.

Artificial Intelligence: More Questions than Answers

09/26/2018 | Dan Feinberg, Technology Editor, I-Connect007
I’ve been covering artificial intelligence (AI) and related technologies for years, particularly at events such as the annual Consumer Electronics Show (CES). As I write this, we are in the run-up to CES 2019, and the Artificial Intelligence Conference in San Francisco, so the AI landscape is likely to change—at an ever-accelerating rate. Let’s look at some of the challenges facing AI now, and then after CES 2019 we can take another look.



Copyright © 2018 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.