A Day with Pete (Starkey)
August 9, 2016 | Barry Matties, I-Connect007Estimated reading time: 17 minutes
Starkey: From an industry that was 400+ strong in the UK, we now have an industry that, if you count very hard, you may find 30 shops. You may find a couple of hundred shops in Germany. That's really the way it's gone. The only people remaining, really, are the people that were the forward-looking ones, that didn't take the same complacent view as the majority and continued their investment, their development and their specialization. They're specialist companies for the most part, and they're servicing the requirements of industries that, for various reasons, are partly security and partly confidence in quality and service, and prefer to trade with local established credible suppliers than to bring in their stuff from offshore.
Matties: Yeah, I think that is certainly something we're seeing in America as well. From a technology point of view, has the technology progressed as fast or to the level that you might have thought it would have by now?
Starkey: Quite honestly, I think the only significant change in the technology has been the era of HDI, the era of the microvia. In my manufacturing days, all of our through-holes, blind holes, and buried holes were produced by mechanical drilling. It was the sort of revolution that happened during the '90s, and it started off in Japan. I can recall going on several technology missions sponsored by our Department of Trade and Industry to discover the magical land of ”Microvia,” which was supposedly a small island close to Japan.
Again, a lot of that technology was OEM driven rather than free market driven. I think during my existence in the UK industry the big changeover was from the OEM shop, because that's where the technology was, to the free market. For the OEM shop, everyone could write his own set of rules and his own set of standards, but it tended to be quite an expensive operation. So guys set up independently and provided a manufacturing service for these OEMs, and they could do it more cost effectively. As a consequence of that, there had to be standardization so that they could offer the same product, or the same manufacturing service to the same standards, to the general market. The industry had to start adopting standards, and part of my early responsibility was to establish capability approvals to, particularly at that time, British standards—later on to European and to world-accepted standards. That was a change which happened early in my years in the industry.
The technology in the first generation, our accepted plated through-hole and multilayer technology, came out of the OEM shops. The microvia technology came principally out of the Japanese OEM shops. The major technology change has been laser drilling rather than mechanical drilling.
Matties: Now I just saw, I think it was Schmoll, drilling sizes half the dimension of a strand of hair. Was that Schmoll?
Starkey: Yeah, it was. It was part of Michael Weinhold's EIPC conference presentation, because Michael has a very good network in the Far East and has spent a lot of time in Japan and always makes a point of attending the JPCA show. We used to mechanically drill holes at 0.6, 0.5, 0.4, 0.3 millimeter, and 0.1 millimeter was about the limit. Then that sort of technology was overshadowed by the laser drilling technology. Laser drilling sort of blasts holes, whereas mechanical drilling accurately cuts the material away from where you want it. He saw examples of mechanical drilling, and mechanical drill bits—it's one thing having the machine, it's the other thing having the tools to use in it—at 30 microns and trending towards 20 microns, which again opens up a new generation of technology.
Matties: That's the thing, there's the board technology, but there's also the actual manufacturing technology, the equipment that we use to produce boards, and now we're getting into the era of inkjets and spray coatings and such. Has that manufacturing process changed the way that you thought it would by now?
Starkey: Quite honestly, designers tended to operate in a closed environment and they just presumed an awful lot of things about the manufacturing process. They'd read a material data sheet, they would set themselves some design rules, and away they'd go, without really any great depth of understanding about the poor guy on the other end of the manufacturing process. Again, from the next stage down the line, the PCB fabricator didn't normally have an awful lot of idea of what happened in the assembly shop, and the assembler didn't have a great appreciation of what necessarily were the limitations of the materials or the finishes that were industry standard on PCBs. Several of us have made a lot of effort over the years to try to encourage the designer to understand the fabrication process.
I spent many, many years manufacturing jobs that probably, if you looked at actual materials capability and process capability, should not have been manufacturable. I think my background in materials and processes and technical service helped. For manufacturing technology, a lot of the metal finishing processes have shown incremental improvements, but no fundamental improvement.
For imaging technology, the original printed circuit was screen printed and then photoresists were introduced, but these were liquid photoresists, which did a very good job but were very messy to use. Then DuPont invented the concept of dry film photoresist, which really revolutionized it, because it meant that with a very straightforward application process you could do very precise imaging with a dry film resist. Dry film has, again, incremental improvements. Liquid resists were reintroduced and liquid resists have been very successful for fine line innerlayer work.Page 2 of 3
Suggested Items
Real Time with… IPC APEX EXPO 2024: Tools, Training, and Trends in Manufacturing Engineering
04/25/2024 | Real Time with...IPC APEX EXPOGuest Editor Kelly Dack and Product Specialist Erik Bateham of Polar Instruments discuss Polar's latest technology, including their role in aiding manufacturing engineers. They highlight the advanced capabilities of Polar's tools and the critical role of signal integrity analysis, as well as the importance of accurate modeling in board manufacturing. Polar's unique training approach and demonstration contact details are also explored.
TTM Celebrates the Grand Opening of Its First Manufacturing Facility in Penang
04/25/2024 | TTM Technologies, Inc.TTM Technologies, Inc., a leading global manufacturer of technology solutions including mission systems, radio frequency (RF) components and RF microwave/microelectronic assemblies, and quick-turn and technologically advanced printed circuit boards (PCBs), officially opened its first manufacturing plant in Penang, Malaysia with an investment of USD200 million (approximately RM958 million).
Listen Up! The Intricacies of PCB Drilling Detailed in New Podcast Episode
04/25/2024 | I-Connect007In episode 5 of the podcast series, On the Line With: Designing for Reality, Nolan Johnson and Matt Stevenson continue down the manufacturing process, this time focusing on the post-lamination drilling process for PCBs. Matt and Nolan delve into the intricacies of the PCB drilling process, highlighting the importance of hole quality, drill parameters, and design optimization to ensure smooth manufacturing. The conversation covers topics such as drill bit sizes, aspect ratios, vias, challenges in drilling, and ways to enhance efficiency in the drilling department.
Elevating PCB Design Engineering With IPC Programs
04/24/2024 | Cory Blaylock, IPCIn a monumental stride for the electronics manufacturing industry, IPC has successfully championed the recognition of the PCB Design Engineer as an official occupation by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL). This pivotal achievement not only underscores the critical role of PCB design engineers within the technology landscape, but also marks the beginning of a transformative journey toward nurturing a robust, skilled workforce ready to propel our industry into the future.
Fujitsu, METRON Collaborate to Drive ESG Success
04/24/2024 | JCN NewswireFujitsu Limited and METRON SAS, a French cleantech company specializing in energy management solutions for industrial decarbonization, today announced a strategic initiative to contribute to the realization of carbon neutrality in the manufacturing industry.